Feeling Drowned Out? The Dunning-Kruger Effect in Dog Training
Let's be honest, it can be utterly frustrating, can't it?
You've dedicated years to truly understanding canine behaviour, investing in science-backed methods, continuous education and honing your craft with genuine care for every dog and human client. You spend hours agonising over case studies, adapting plans for individual dogs and celebrating the tiny, incremental wins that lead to lasting change.
Yet, you often scroll through social media or have a quick google for dog trainers in your area and see others – perhaps with far less genuine expertise or formal education – making huge, sweeping promises, shouting the loudest, and seeming to grab all the attention. "Guaranteed fix in three sessions!", "My method works for every dog, every time!"
It's enough to make you wonder if you're doing something wrong. More than likely, it’s just the Dunning-Kruger effect at play… something which is particularly rampant in our unregulated dog training and animal behaviour industry.
Heard of the Dunning-Kruger Effect? Let's Connect the Dots
Many of you are likely already familiar with the Dunning-Kruger effect. It describes a cognitive bias where people with low ability in a particular area tend to overestimate their own competence. They simply don't know enough to realise how much they don't know. It's like someone who's only ever built a simple Lego car confidently declaring they're ready to design a Formula 1 race car. Their limited experience means they can't even perceive the vast complexity and skill required.
Conversely, highly competent individuals (yes, that's you!) often underestimate their expertise, assuming that tasks that feel straightforward or logical to them are also easy for others. You understand the nuances, the "it depends" scenarios, and the complexities of behaviour, so you naturally speak with more caution and less absolute certainty. This can make us, the true experts, second-guess ourselves, or feel like we're not "marketing hard enough" because we're not making those bold, unqualified claims.
The Four Stages of Competence: A Framework for Our Industry
Now, let's explore the Four Stages of Competence, a learning model that perfectly illustrates how expertise develops and how the Dunning-Kruger effect fits in:
Unconscious Incompetence:
You don't know what you don't know. (This is where the Dunning-Kruger effect's overconfidence often thrives. Individuals at this stage might believe they're already excellent trainers, because they haven't encountered enough complex scenarios or deep learning to realise their gaps.)Conscious Incompetence:
You know what you don't know. You've encountered challenges, perhaps made mistakes and realised the vastness of the subject. This stage can feel overwhelming or frustrating, as you become acutely aware of your limitations.Conscious Competence:
You know how to do it, but it requires effort and concentration. You're applying your knowledge, problem-solving, and actively thinking through each step.Unconscious Competence:
You can do it naturally and automatically, without conscious effort. Your knowledge is deeply integrated, and you've handled so many diverse cases that you can fluidly adapt. (This is often where many of you probably sit, at least with some of your skills. What feels easy or intuitive to you now took years of dedicated learning and practice.)
The problem arises when individuals stuck in Unconscious Incompetence believe they are already at Unconscious Competence. They simply haven't had the experiences that would move them to Conscious Incompetence, where true learning and growth begin.
AND Yes, you guessed it… this often translates directly into their marketing!
The Unregulated Wild West: Why Our Industry is Ripe for Overconfidence
Our wonderful world of dog training and animal behaviour isn't exactly regulated, is it? Unlike vets, doctors or even electricians, there's no mandatory licensing or universal certification. This means the barrier to entry is, well, pretty low.
Anyone can call themselves a "dog trainer" tomorrow, often with very little formal education or supervised experience. And, while that allows for passion and dedication to flourish, it also creates a perfect storm for the Dunning-Kruger effect to run wild.
The 'Instant Expert' Phenomenon (Unconscious Incompetence):
Think about it: someone attends a short weekend course, reads a couple of popular books, perhaps successfully trains their own dog or a few friends' dogs. Armed with this nascent understanding, they suddenly feel like they've got the whole game figured out.
Their limited understanding actually prevents them from seeing the vast landscape of canine ethology, learning theory, behavioural modification techniques and the critical thinking required to analyse individual cases. Because they are in the stage of Unconscious Incompetence, they don't know what they don't know, leading to:
Bold, unqualified claims: "I can fix any dog's reactivity in three sessions!" (Sound familiar? You know full well that reactivity often takes months of dedicated, careful work, adapting to individual dogs and their environments.) Or, "Your dog just needs to know you're the alpha!" – a concept long debunked by science but simple enough to grasp at a superficial level.
Dismissal of nuanced, ethical approaches: "Positive reinforcement is just permissive; you need to dominate the dog!" They might genuinely believe their old-school, confrontational methods are the only way, simply because they haven't learned or understood the science behind modern, welfare-centred approaches.
Aggressive, often misleading marketing: Because they're blissfully unaware of their own limitations (stuck in Unconscious Incompetence), they don't have the ethical qualms or scientific caution that would naturally temper their marketing messages. This allows them to shout louder, use sensational language and make promises that seasoned professionals know are impossible, unethical, or even dangerous.
Simplistic solutions to complex problems: They'll often blame everything on "dominance" or a lack of "respect," missing the underlying emotions, medical issues or environmental stressors that you know are often at play in a dog's behaviour. "Oh, your dog growls at strangers? He just needs to be shown who's boss!"… a dangerous oversimplification that ignores the root cause of the growl.
You: The Ethical, Knowledgeable and Quiet Expert (Conscious/Unconscious Competence):
And then there's you. You've invested in comprehensive education (perhaps multiple certifications, degrees, mentorships), spent years navigating complex cases (the fearful rescues, the misunderstood ‘resource guarders’, the dogs with complex medical histories), understanding individual differences and continually refining your approach.
You know that there are no "quick fixes" and that true behavioural change is a journey of patience, consistency, and kindness. This deep expertise often translates into:
Nuanced, honest communication: You talk about working towards goals, not guaranteeing instant transformations. You speak in probabilities and possibilities ("I’m optimistic that we can significantly reduce reactivity," "It's likely to take X months of consistent work"), not certainties, because you understand the multitude of variables involved. You've moved beyond the black-and-white thinking of early stages.
A commitment to continuous learning: You know the science is always evolving, and you're always seeking out new research, attending conferences, and refining your skills. There's always more to learn because the world of canine behaviour is endlessly fascinating and complex. This is the hallmark of Conscious Competence and the drive towards deeper Unconscious Competence.
A truly individualised approach: You know every dog and every human client is unique, requiring a tailored strategy, not a cookie-cutter solution. Your deep competence allows you to see the individual.
Marketing that feels, well, less aggressive: Your integrity means you won't make hyperbolic claims. You focus on education, building trust and showcasing your genuine expertise. This can sometimes feel like you're not "competing" in the same arena as the loud, overconfident crowd, simply because you refuse to compromise your ethics. Good on you!
How to Stand Out (Ethically!) in a Noisy Crowd
It's frustrating when genuine expertise gets overshadowed by flashy, unfounded promises. You know the quality of your work, the care you put into every case, and the real, lasting results you achieve.
The good news is: clients who truly value ethical, effective, and sustainable solutions are looking for you. Your job is to help them find you, understand your value, and trust your process.
Educate, Don't Just Promote:
Use your marketing to demystify the reality of dog behaviour and training. Instead of just saying "I fix barking," explain why dogs bark (fear, excitement, attention-seeking) and the process involved in addressing it. By explaining the "how" and "why," you build trust and position yourself as the true, knowledgeable expert. You're not just selling a service; you're offering understanding and partnership.
Share Your "Why":
Why are you so passionate about ethical, science-backed methods? What drives your continuous learning? Perhaps it was a challenging rescue dog or a specific mentor. This personal connection resonates deeply with clients looking for genuine care and commitment. It’s about more than just skills; it’s about your values.
Showcase Your Nuance and Process:
While others make sweeping guarantees, highlight the individualised care you provide. Talk about the journey, the partnership with the client and the long-term, positive outcomes that come from understanding and patience. Instead of "I train loose lead walking," you might say, "I teach you how to help your dog develop polite lead walking manners, adapting to their pace and motivation, for enjoyable, relaxed walks together."
Embrace Your Expertise (Without the Fluff):
You are highly competent. Don't shy away from that. Share your qualifications, your continued professional development, and your success stories… but always with the humility and transparency that defines an ethical professional.
Use case studies (with client permission, of course!) to illustrate complex problems and how your thoughtful, nuanced approach brought about positive change. "This little terrier arrived with severe fear of strangers. Through careful desensitisation and counter-conditioning, we helped her feel safe enough to enjoy walks again, celebrating every tiny step forward."
Focus on Building Trust, Not Just Sales:
Ethical marketing is about building relationships. It's about being consistent and transparent, empowering clients to make informed decisions. This can help you to attract the right clients… those who are willing to invest in genuine, lasting solutions and who align with your compassionate values. You're not just a service provider; you're a trusted guide.
Remember, the Dunning-Kruger effect might make the less knowledgeable seem louder but it's your deep understanding, ethical approach, and unwavering commitment to genuine, positive results that will ultimately build a thriving, sustainable business.
Don't let their noise diminish your brilliance or cause you to question your immense value. The right clients are out there and they're looking for you.
Ready to translate your ethical expertise into powerful, honest marketing that truly attracts your ideal clients?
My online course The Obvious Choice is designed specifically for ethical dog trainers and animal behaviourists like you, helping you cut through the noise and market your services with integrity and confidence.
You don't need to shout louder; you just need to speak to the right people in the right way. The Obvious Choice helps you to do exactly that!
Click on the button below for more details.
Please feel free to share this article…
READ MORE Posts like this ONE
